Closing questions

What happens if a co-op sale falls through after board approval?

Board approval does not close a deal. What happens to escrow, the approval and the timeline when a NYC co-op deal collapses after the board has signed off.

What happens if a co-op sale falls through after board approval?

Quick Answer

Approval does not close a deal. If financing collapses, a party defaults or a lien surfaces late, the contract controls: escrow is released under its terms, the approval usually lapses, and a replacement purchaser starts the package over. The seller loses the weeks the first approval consumed.

The most common late failure is financing. A commitment is issued subject to conditions, and a change in employment, a new debt, an appraisal problem or a building-level issue can undo it. Where the mortgage contingency is still alive, the purchaser cancels and escrow returns the down payment. Where the contingency has expired, the exposure is real.

Late-surfacing money problems account for most of the rest. The continuation of the co-op lien search turns up a judgment docketed after the original search, an old UCC filing nobody terminated, or maintenance arrears larger than reported. These are usually curable at the table with a payoff and a holdback, but they move the date.

Approval itself is not indefinite. Boards commonly treat an approval as tied to the purchaser and the terms submitted, so a material change, a new lender or a long delay can require resubmission. A different purchaser always starts fresh: there is no transferring an approval from one buyer to the next.

The seller’s protection is drafting done at contract. Clear default provisions, an outside date, a defined escrow release procedure and an obligation on the purchaser to keep the lender file current cost nothing to include and decide who bears the loss when a deal fails in its final week.

Does the down payment come back if the buyer cannot close?

It depends on why. A timely cancellation under a live mortgage contingency returns the deposit. A purchaser who simply cannot perform after the contingency has run is in default, and the contract typically lets the seller retain the down payment as liquidated damages. Escrow does not release on either theory without written direction.

How long does it take to restart with a new buyer?

Realistically the full cycle again: a new contract, a new board package, a new lender file and a new place in the building’s meeting calendar. Sellers who have been through one failed approval often ask for a stronger financing profile or a shorter contingency on the second contract, which is a reasonable response.

What else should you read before closing?

In the glossary

Questions this raises

Have a closing coming up?

Tell us about the transaction. An attorney reads every intake form and responds the same business day.

Legal Disclaimer: This page is general information about New York practice. It is not legal advice, it does not account for the terms of any particular contract, building or transaction, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. This is attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee similar outcomes.