Closing questions
What are HDFC co-op income caps?
HDFC co-ops cap purchaser household income under the Private Housing Finance Law, against an area median income ceiling. How the cap is measured and verified.
What are HDFC co-op income caps?
Quick Answer
An HDFC is a housing development fund corporation formed under Article XI of the Private Housing Finance Law to hold affordable housing, often a building the City transferred to its tenants. The affordability is not aspirational. It is written into the building’s governing documents: the certificate of incorporation, the City deed and, where one exists, a regulatory agreement.
Section 576 of the Private Housing Finance Law, carried in the certificate of incorporation and repeated in the City deed, sets the limit at six times annual maintenance plus utilities, or seven times where the household has three or more dependents, subject to a ceiling of 165 percent of area median income. Where the deed or a regulatory agreement sets a lower limit, such as 120 percent of AMI, that limit governs instead. Because the formula runs off each apartment’s own maintenance, two HDFC buildings on the same street can produce different caps, so the figure has to come from the building’s own documents.
Verification is documentary. The managing agent or the board will ask for tax returns, pay stubs and sometimes an affidavit, and it counts the income of everyone who will occupy the unit rather than only the person on the contract. Bonus income, self-employment income and a working adult child in the household all matter.
The failure mode the firm sees most often is a purchaser who signs a contract, then discovers the cap after the package is assembled. Confirming the applicable cap and running the household math before signing is a short conversation that avoids a dead deal and a fight over the down payment.
Does an HDFC income cap apply to assets as well as income?
The statutory test is written against income, but some governing documents and some boards also look at assets, on the view that a purchaser with substantial holdings is not the household the program exists for. Because the terms are building-specific, the asset question has to be answered from the documents rather than from the general rule.
Will a lender finance an HDFC co-op purchase?
Some will and many will not. The income cap, any resale restriction and the flip tax running to the corporation all complicate the collateral, and lenders differ on whether they are comfortable. Identify a lender that already works in HDFC buildings before the contract, rather than assuming the usual bank will fund it.
What else should you read before closing?
In the glossary
- Flip taxA transfer fee charged by a co-op or, less often, a condominium when a unit changes hands. It is a creature of the building's governing documents, ...
- Proprietary leaseThe occupancy lease a co-op corporation grants a shareholder for a specific unit. It is assigned at closing together with the stock certificate for...
- Offering planThe sponsor's filed disclosure document for a co-op or condominium, carrying its budget, share or common interest allocation, building rules and sp...
- Maintenance (co-op)The monthly charge a co-op levies on each shareholder, covering building operations plus that shareholder's share of real estate taxes and the unde...
- Stock certificate (co-op)The certificate evidencing the shares allocated to a co-op apartment. Shares and the proprietary lease travel together and cannot be sold separatel...
Questions this raises
- Can you resell an HDFC co-op at market price?HDFC resale is limited by the building’s own documents: a purchaser income cap, a flip tax to the corporation and, where one exists, a resale price...
- What is the risk in a land lease co-op?A land lease co-op rents the ground under the building. Rent resets can raise maintenance sharply and the lease end date limits financing and resal...
- Does a condop close as a co-op or as a condo?A condop apartment closes as a co-op share transfer even though the building is divided into condominium units. What that hybrid changes at the clo...
- What is in a co-op board package?A NYC co-op board package carries the application, contract, tax returns, financial statement, lender commitment and reference letters. What each i...
- Who pays the flip tax in a New York co-op sale?A flip tax usually comes off the seller’s proceeds, but plenty of New York buildings shift it to the purchaser. Why the rider has to name the payin...
- What should a lender check in a co-op loan file?A co-op lender underwrites the building as well as the borrower: financials, underlying mortgage, arrears, land lease, financing cap and recognitio...
Building types
- HDFC co-opAn affordable cooperative formed under Article XI of the Private Housing Finance Law, with an income cap on purchasers and a flip tax that runs to ...
- Mitchell-Lama co-opA limited-equity cooperative in the State and City Mitchell-Lama program, sold from a waiting list at a formula price rather than on the open market.
- Standard co-opThe ordinary New York City cooperative: you buy shares in a corporation and receive a proprietary lease to occupy a specific apartment.
Have a closing coming up?
Tell us about the transaction. An attorney reads every intake form and responds the same business day.
Legal Disclaimer: This page is general information about New York practice. It is not legal advice, it does not account for the terms of any particular contract, building or transaction, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. This is attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee similar outcomes.