Zoning and land use
Rezonings and zoning text amendments
A rezoning changes the map for specific lots. A text amendment changes the rulebook citywide or by district type. They follow different Charter paths.
What is the difference between a rezoning and a zoning text amendment?
Quick Answer
Discretionary approvals
Who does this land on?
Owners near a proposed map change, developers whose project needs either one, and anyone whose plan depends on a rule that a pending amendment would change.
What governs it?
- The City Charter provisions governing zoning map amendments as listed land use actions
- The separate City Charter section governing amendments to the text of the Zoning Resolution
- The Department of City Planning, which sponsors or reviews both and refers them for public comment
- The City Planning Commission and the City Council, which act on both
- Environmental review, which applies to both because both are discretionary actions
How does the process run?
- Identify which one the project actually needs, because a use barred by the text is not fixed by a map change and a district that bars the use is not fixed by a text change
- For a map amendment, run the full public review sequence after certification
- For a text amendment, expect referral to community boards and borough boards for comment, a City Planning Commission hearing and vote, then City Council action
- Complete environmental review before either is certified or heard
- Track pending amendments that affect the site, because the version in effect at filing governs the filing
- Reduce the approval to a filing: an amendment is not a permit and does not by itself authorize any work
Where does it bite in a transaction?
- A project waits on a map change when the barrier is a text provision that the map change will not touch
- A filing is made under a rule that a pending amendment repeals before the permit issues
- A site is acquired on the strength of a citywide amendment whose conditions the lot does not satisfy
- A schedule treats a text amendment as faster than a rezoning without checking the referral periods
Which is faster?
Neither reliably. A text amendment skips some of the steps a map amendment takes, but a citywide amendment draws citywide comment and the political calendar is the real variable. Both are measured in many months from certification, and both are preceded by preparation that is usually longer than the review itself.
Can a private applicant sponsor a text amendment?
Yes. Private applicants do file text amendments, commonly narrow ones written to reach a defined set of circumstances. The narrower the drafting, the more it resembles relief for one site, and the more closely the Commission and the Council will read it as exactly that.
Does a rezoning protect what is already built?
A use lawfully established before the change generally continues as a non-conforming use, and a building that complied when built generally continues as a non-complying building. What a downzoning takes away is unbuilt capacity, which is not a vested right unless work has progressed far enough for vesting rules to apply.
What else should you read before you file or sign?
In the glossary
- Certificate of Occupancy (C of O)The Department of Buildings document that fixes a building's legal use and occupancy. Lenders and title companies read it to confirm the property c...
- Zoning lot certificateA recorded declaration combining tax lots into one zoning lot for development purposes. Waivers and consents from affected owners and lienholders a...
Zoning and land use
- ULURP, the uniform land use review procedureULURP is the public review process for rezonings and other listed land use actions, on a fixed clock that starts only after certification. Here is ...
- Environmental review of a land use applicationDiscretionary approvals trigger environmental review in New York City. As-of-right filings do not. Here is what the assessment covers and where it ...
- R, C and M zoning districts in New York CityEvery NYC lot sits in a residential, commercial or manufacturing district, often with an overlay or a special district on top of it. Here is how to...
- Legal non-conforming use and grandfatheringA use lawful when it started can continue after the zoning changes, but the protection is narrow and it can be lost. Here is what it covers and how...
- Accessory dwelling unitsRecent zoning text amendments opened a path for accessory dwelling units in parts of New York City. Whether your lot qualifies is a parcel-level qu...
Have a closing coming up?
Tell us about the transaction. An attorney reads every intake form and responds the same business day.
Legal Disclaimer: This page is general information about New York practice. It is not legal advice, it does not account for the terms of any particular contract, building or transaction, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. This is attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee similar outcomes.